A Texas Court Just Confirmed: You Can Leave a City's ETJ, and the City Can't Stop You

Twenty-five Texas cities got together and sued the State over a law that lets landowners leave a city's extraterritorial jurisdiction without city permission. Last month, a Texas appellate court ruled against every single one of their arguments.

That's a long way of saying something simple: if you own property in a city's ETJ and want out, the law protecting your right to leave just got a lot sturdier.


What is an ETJ, and why would you want out of it?

Extraterritorial jurisdiction, ETJ for short, is the ring of unincorporated land just outside a city's limits where the city often gets a say over certain things: platting, subdivisions, signage, roads. You're not inside the city. You don't get city services. But the city can still regulate certain things about how you use your land.

For a long time, getting released from a city's ETJ required the city's consent. If the city didn't want to let you go, you were stuck.

That changed with a 2023 law, Senate Bill 2038. The new law gave landowners two paths out: a petition signed by a majority of landowners in the area to be disannexed, or an election in which area residents could vote to leave. (By the way, the petitioning landowners can define the “area” to be disannexed, meaning a disannexation petition can cover a huge area with multiple parcels, a single parcel, or even a portion of a parcel.)

Here's something important about the new law: If a majority of the area residents petition for release and the city doesn't act within 45 days, the release happens automatically, by operation of law. A city might ignore the petition, or even deny it, but disannexation happens anyway as long as the petition meets the law’s basic requirements.


Why 25 cities fought back, and why they lost

Cities didn't love losing control of their ETJs, and a group of them, joined by a municipal development district, sued the State directly, arguing the new law was unconstitutional. They threw a bunch of arguments against the wall: that the new law conflicted with older law requiring city consent, that the new law violated their home-rule authority, that it improperly handed legislative power to private landowners, that it was unconstitutionally vague, that it denied landowners due process, that it violated equal protection, that it broke existing development contracts, and that it amounted to an illegal local law and an unconstitutional gift of public funds.

The court rejected all of these arguments.

A couple of the rejections are worth understanding, because they get at what the law is actually doing. The cities argued the petition process improperly hands landowners a legislative power that only the state can delegate. The court disagreed: the law doesn't give landowners any regulatory authority at all. It simply offers them a choice between being governed by the city's rules or the county's. That's not lawmaking. That's an election between two existing sets of rules.

The cities also argued landowners weren't given fair notice or a chance to be heard before release. The court pointed out that the petition process itself requires gathering signatures from landowners in the affected area, which means talking to the landowners in the area before anything happens. The process builds in the types of conversations that the cities claimed were missing.


This win isn't just theoretical for our clients

We've already seen this exact fight play out directly. One of our clients petitioned to release their property from a city's ETJ earlier this year. The city denied the petition, relying on the same legal theories that the court of appeals just rejected.

We've gone back to that city with the ruling in hand and asked the city to honor the petition and remove the property from its ETJ map, as the law requires. That's not a hypothetical application of this decision. It's exactly the kind of situation this ruling was written for.


What this means if you're in a city's ETJ

If you've submitted an ETJ release petition and been denied, especially on constitutional grounds, the city’s denial is almost surely unlawful. The ETJ-removal law has now been tested against nearly every argument a city could make, and the new law prevailed.

You don't need the city's blessing to leave its ETJ. You need a compliant petition, enough neighbors willing to sign it, and a good lawyer to ensure the city follows the law.

Next
Next

We Won at the Fifth Circuit: Lake Austin Homeowners' Case Revived